Skip to content

Ditch Spotify: How to Build a 'Buy Once' Digital Music Library with Plex

BuyOnceHub Team • • 9 min read

Own Your Music Collection

Spotify costs $10.99/month ($131.88/year). Over 10 years, that's $1,318.80—and you never own any music. With Plex and your own music files, you can build a library you own forever.

Why Own Your Music?

The Problem with Streaming

  • No ownership: Cancel your subscription, lose access to everything
  • Price increases: Spotify raised prices multiple times
  • Missing content: Songs disappear when licenses expire
  • Data usage: Streaming uses data on mobile
  • Offline limitations: Limited offline downloads

The Benefits of Ownership

  • You own the files: Music is yours forever
  • No monthly fees: One-time investment
  • Complete control: Organize how you want
  • No DRM: Play on any device
  • Offline access: Works without internet

Building Your Music Library

Option 1: Buy Digital Music (One-Time)

Sources:

  • Bandcamp: Artists get 85-90% of sales, DRM-free
  • 7digital: Large catalog, DRM-free MP3s
  • Amazon Music Store: Buy individual tracks/albums
  • iTunes Store: Buy music (DRM-free since 2009)
  • Qobuz: High-quality downloads
Cost: $0.99-$1.29 per song, $9.99-$15.99 per album

Break-even: If you buy 10-15 albums per year, you break even with Spotify in 8-10 years, then own the music forever.

Option 2: CDs (Physical Media)

Sources:

  • Used CD stores ($1-5 per CD)
  • Online marketers ($5-15 per CD)
  • Library sales ($1-3 per CD)
  • Garage sales and thrift stores
Process: 1. Buy CDs 2. Rip to computer (MP3, FLAC, or other format) 3. Organize in Plex 4. Sell or store CDs

Cost: $2-10 per album Break-even: 1-2 years vs. Spotify, then own forever

Option 3: Vinyl + Digital Downloads

Many vinyl releases include digital download codes:

  • Buy vinyl for collecting
  • Get digital files included
  • Best of both worlds

Setting Up Plex for Music

What is Plex?

Plex is free media server software that organizes and streams your music (and videos) to any device. It's like having your own personal Spotify.

Setup Steps

1. Install Plex Server

  • Download Plex Media Server (free)
  • Install on your computer or NAS
  • Create a Plex account (free)
2. Organize Your Music
  • Create a Music folder
  • Organize by Artist/Album
  • Add album art and metadata
  • Let Plex scan and organize
3. Access Your Music
  • Plex mobile apps (iOS/Android)
  • Web browser
  • Smart TV apps
  • Desktop apps
  • Any device with Plex app

Plex Features

  • Music organization: Automatic metadata and album art
  • Playlists: Create and sync playlists
  • Offline sync: Download for offline listening
  • Multi-device: Access from any device
  • Sharing: Share with family/friends
  • No subscription required: Free for personal use

Cost Comparison

Spotify (Subscription)

  • Cost: $10.99/month ($131.88/year)
  • 5-Year Cost: $659.40
  • 10-Year Cost: $1,318.80
  • Ownership: None (lose access if you cancel)

Plex + Owned Music

Setup Cost:

  • Plex Server: Free (or $5/month for Plex Pass features)
  • NAS/Storage: $300-500 (optional, can use existing computer)
  • Music Library: $500-1,000 (buy 50-100 albums)
Total One-Time: $800-1,500 5-Year Cost: $800-1,500 (one-time) 10-Year Cost: $800-1,500 (one-time)

Break-even: 6-12 years, then free forever

Building Your Library Over Time

You don't need to buy everything at once:

Year 1: Buy 20-30 favorite albums ($200-400) Year 2: Add 20-30 more ($200-400) Year 3: Add another 20-30 ($200-400) After 3 years: You have 60-90 albums, paid $600-1,200 total

Compare to Spotify: $395.64 over 3 years, with nothing to show for it.

Where to Get Music

Best Sources for Digital Music

1. Bandcamp: Support artists directly, DRM-free 2. 7digital: Large catalog, good prices 3. Qobuz: High-quality audio files 4. Amazon Music Store: Convenient, integrated 5. iTunes Store: Large selection

Best Sources for CDs

1. Used CD stores: $2-5 per CD 2. Online marketplaces: eBay, Discogs 3. Library sales: $1-3 per CD 4. Garage sales: $0.50-2 per CD 5. Thrift stores: Very cheap

Organizing Your Collection

File Organization

Recommended Structure: ``` Music/ Artist Name/ Album Name/ Track Number - Track Name.mp3 ```

Metadata

  • Use MusicBrainz Picard (free) to tag files
  • Add album art automatically
  • Fix incorrect metadata
  • Ensure consistent formatting

Plex Organization

Plex automatically:

  • Organizes by artist/album
  • Fetches album art
  • Adds metadata
  • Creates playlists
  • Syncs across devices

Mobile Access

Plex mobile apps (free):

  • iOS: Full-featured, free
  • Android: Full-featured, free
  • Offline sync: Download for offline
  • Streaming: Stream from your server
  • Playlists: Create and sync playlists
Just like Spotify, but with your own music.

Plex Pass (Optional)

Plex Pass ($5/month or $120 lifetime) adds:

  • Offline mobile sync
  • Advanced features
  • Early access to features
  • Hardware transcoding
Not required for basic music streaming. Free version works great for music.

The Bottom Line

Building your own music library with Plex costs more upfront but pays for itself in 6-12 years. After that, you own your music forever—no monthly fees, no subscription cancellation, no lost access.

If you're paying for Spotify and plan to use music streaming for more than 5 years, consider building your own library. You'll own your music, support artists directly (via Bandcamp), and save money long-term.

Start by buying your 20-30 favorite albums, set up Plex, and build from there. Your future self will thank you.